Share your feedback, comments and reviews for FIFA 11.
FIFA 11 was released on September 28th. FIFA 10, the previous version of the game received over 16,000 ideas from gamers via FIFPlay.com.
Here we invite you to give your feedback, comments and reviews for FIFA 11, to share it with other FIFA gamers and the FIFA developers themselves at EA!
FIFA 11 was released on September 28th. FIFA 10, the previous version of the game received over 16,000 ideas from gamers via FIFPlay.com.
Here we invite you to give your feedback, comments and reviews for FIFA 11, to share it with other FIFA gamers and the FIFA developers themselves at EA!
Comments 926
- AI aggressively takes on every header and free ball, whereas own players don't care about reaching the ball at all
- Own defenders don't care about marking the forward reaching for the cross
- Own players in possession stupidly run with the ball into opponents and lose ball
- Own wingers don't start running to position themselves for a through ball
- Own forwards "hide" behind or between defenders, but always in close range to them
All these facts made it impossible to win (and killed all fun!) playing only with my VirtualPro, so I started playing the whole team and now I can win games, but there are still heavy flaws:
- It's almost impossible to get through in a one on one situation with a forward against a defender, they almost always (95%) push my forward away and get the ball
- The defender not controlled by me still doesn't care about marking his opponent when a cross is played
- more frequently than it could be accepted the direction of passing in detail (in front of the player- in his back, difference between normal pass and throughball in equal situations) is not corresponding to my input or explainable at all - very frustrating!!
Besides gameplay issues, I found various other details, the most important:
- Game frequently freezes for some seconds
- extensive loading times
- Why are the details for my Virtual Pro in the career-menu hidden under "options"??
- In a cup match, when the players get on the green, the round (1st round, Quarterfinal...) is not stated on the strap, just the name of the cup
- There is no access to a synopsis of my last games while in career mode
But, why no career mode? I mean, not every1 has a ps3 or and xbox. And the Virtual Pro's stats dont save at all. I played like a 100 games and his stats are still 0-0-0
Although its awesome
why fifa 11 sucks
1. the players are to sloooooow! the whole gameplay is to slow.. messi, ronaldo, eto'o (for example) they're all supposed to be fast but how come they're faster with the ball (pressing right anolog forward) than without??? it doesnt make any sense.
2. when i play against the computer on proffessional or even semi-pro, its almost impossible to take the ball from them.and when i intercept, the ball always seem to find its way back to the opponent without me even get the chance to controll the ball.. it would be realistic if it happens sometimes but not ALL THE TIME!! 9 out of 10 times i swear.
3. menus are slow.. everything with this game is slow!
4. so many bugs! i understand that bugs are inevitable, but this game takes the price!
examples, i chose AC Milan, but when i go to squad, all of a sudden im Brazil! WTF!!!!!???????
ronaldinho becomes white, refree starts givin 100 yellow cards, i shot at the crossbar and the ball freezed there for about 10 seconds.offsides when its not supposed to be. its understandable if its a matter of a couple inches (lets call it human mistake of the refree) but im talkin about 5-10 yards onside
5. apparently you can intercept from behind really easy now.
6. the game is sloooow!!! honestly i fall asleep when i play this game, its so boring!
fifa 09 - 8/10
fifa 10 - 9.5/10
world cup 2010 - 9.9/10
fifa 11 - 4/10!
This years Fifa is poor especially all the hype:
-Pro Passing does not work as the power bar is tempermental especially with short passes as you just press the button yet it powers it across the box yet a hold it in for a through ball and he just touches it and runs away.
-Be a pro Keeper, good idea poorly produced as you could go away for you tea and still not have had a shot into you.
-AI is so bad its unreal, they never make any runs and when they do they run miles offside. Also in BAP mode they take an age to play a pass opting to do some stepovers while losing the ball.
-The refs are a joke and its impossible to get a flowing game when its a freekick for nothing and you get booked so easily yet you could go flying into a slide challenge from behind and get away with nothing.
-The personality traits are also poor as there predictable and i dont think they add anything apart from a wee sentance explaining he is a good dribbler also nearly every tall player has strenth and good aerial ability which is just lazy although thats wha i expect with Fifa.
-The menus are far too slow with anything especially online when you get timed it takes around 10 seconds to get into the team management then you dont have alot of time to change things. I dislike PES but atleast there menus are usable.
-The game seems to have a point in the pitch where if you pass it the computer defender become superman and can outpace, outstrenth and can time a perfect tackle everytime nomatter who they are or are up against making it impossible.
I struggle to find any improvements in the game and again the only passable feature is the BAP clubs and even then EA servers are dire. A think PES is going to get the upper hand again as Fifa are getting worse.
how many times can i tackle and it "bounce" back to there players... 8 shot on goal 1 scored where as real 1 shot 1 goal......i could go on but i cant be arsed WP EA
I enjoy playing it but it hasnt really progressed much from fifa 10. if anything it has got worse.
Great Graphics though.
I get the "build up" play idea but its just not fun anymore. Im trading my copy in tomorrow, just a shame i waited this long.
oh, also the collisions are just humorous and why, when streaming into the box 3 feet ahead of the last man, does Ronaldo seemingly slow down to wait for the defender and reach out to hold his hand?? and then because of the “pressureâ€, cant get a clean shot off?
I am perfectly happy with the game (full version) UNTIL I crank up the difficulty level to world class +. What on earth were you thinking when developing the AI for this game? It is absolutely PATHETIC that every 1 and a half passes the ball is being intercepted even though the pass itself is flawless. SHOW me a real life football game where interceptions happen as often as in this game! (and not just one example) Defenders always domme my strikers even though my VirtualPro (hereafter VP) has a rating of 88 overall by now. It simply feels that where as the opponent AI increases with higher difficulty (which is to be expected and absolutely alright) my team dumbs down a fair bit. Meaning passes become ridiculously stupid and slow, no runs are being made or runs are being made when there is absolutely no use to even bother because even a blind person could see my striker run in offside.
Secondly, what on earth happened to the game flow? Counter Attack play is way to slow and in 90% of scenarios the defenders will either outrun, outfight, outplay or outtackle me regardless of how well I time skill moves and/or plays/shots. I am not saying I am the greatest FIFA 11 player there is but for the love of god I would play better than that in real life.
Thirdly,
Runs in general are pathetic. One or 2 decent position plays made by my team's AI controlled players are offset by 20 retarded moves, passes and/or runs. Yes you read correctly...RETARDED. When playing a football simulation that claims itself to be the closest thing to the real deal (and I have played football since I am 6 years old now 26 so that makes 20 years) I expect my team AI to be smarter than myself in terms of positioning, holding the opponent off, making runs etc.
Fourthly,
Why did you not just expand on the mainly great job you did with the World Cup Edition? Why take the game backwards in terms of development? Yes graphics have been polished, yes movement have been polished, yes it does look great but it LACKS DEPTH!
Overall,
if I were to give the game a rating where 1 is the worst and 10 the best I would unfortunately not be able to give it more than a 5 ( and that's on a good day).
You had so much promised delivered in retrospect to WC 2010 and yet failed to expand on those advances and rather included a "Be a Keeper" mode that whilst being refreshing to play every now and then BORES the hell out of me especially when one of the VP achievements requires me to play an entire season as one.
I really do wonder if anybody responsible for game developing etc actually finds these type of pages and really reads them. If not well create a new job I am more than happy to read all of them and compile what people say in an orderly fashion.
But seriously guys if you don't get decent updates out there and finally really make improvements with FIFA 12 than you won't just lose me as a paying customer but many many more as I have searched the net for negative feedback and it seems a lot of folks agree with me despite your increased sales for FIFA 11.
I think they've improved immensely in just one year. The game just keeps getting better and better.
If you have a virtual pro and are looking for a team, send a request to sign to : Arcadian FC
Thanks
basically, tackling has become too easy! waaaay too easy. Not just for defenders but most players. Almost impossible to hold up or protect the ball, or dibble\turn with any enjoyment. I now play with only 2 defenders as just dont need any more!! spend every game camped in opposition half trying to break them down, defending the odd counter attack, with ease. think i conceded about 6 goals in first 2 seasons. whats the point in that? not exactly banging them in at the other end despite dominating possesion and chances. if i see 1-0 one more time....! :(
All other aspects are great but this just overshadows all the positives. Sorely dissapointed, still way better than PES this year again but think i'll go back to Fifa 10, which on balance, became too easy. regular 7-0's shouldnt happen on legendary level but at least it was fun times.... need to find the middle ground!
All those complaining need to get into ArenaTraining Mode n practice...
press select during Arena and practice more n more n more...
PLUS PES 2011 is gonna be MUCH better this year. WHY? b/c they are reaching a whole NEW MARKET. They are including the 2nd best club tournament in the world with the HIGHEST reputation in the Americas, the COPA LIBERTADORES. Every south american is gonna drop the fifa 11 this year and play PES 2011. Include me in that list.
i extremly like this game, i hope that fifa 11 is more and more harder and more realistic than previous version. I think power of world class and leagened playing mode is not quite enough .i think next version is more and more power ful than previous version .and world cup and uefa cup might add this game.
very happy to have FIFA 11
"Be a Pro"
* Better now a player's career is longer than 4 years, like in FIFA 10 (Duh! what genuis decided that when they made FIFA 10!)
* However, they've now merged "Be a pro - Player" mode into the Manager and Player Manager Modes. - i.e. you have sit to wait for each individual day to CRAWL past (whilst it sims player transfer, results, and a ton of other piddling minutiae I couldn't give a toss about, in the background. End result? up to FIVE minutes before I can go from finishing a game one week, to playing the next weeks game!! HOW CAN YOU BE SO STUPID EA!!?? DID YOU UNDERTAKE ANY PLAY TESTING AT ALL!? - I highly doubt it.
Even worse - If your Pro gets injured for a long period, you have to sit there waiting for EACH INDIVIDUAL DAY to CRAWWWL past, Then "Sim" the games you can't play in because you're injured (Which takes aaaages, unlike FIFA 10). ARE YOU TRYING TO PUNISH YOUR LOYAL FANS AND CREATE A PAINFUL AN EXPERIENCE AS POSSIBLE EA!? IF so, mission accomplished
If you'd left the Pro (player) experience exactly as it was in FIFA 10, but just extended the length of career to what it should have been in the first place, it would have been great.
Instead, it is such a horridly painful & frustrating experience, that I've already given up trying to play this mode in FIFA 11, after just 6 "Career" games! EA, do you understand an average league season is 40+ games a year? More if you include Cup games, European competition games, International games, etc, etc!? Did you not think how incredibly tedious it would become for the person playing the game to have to wait at least 5 mins for EACH GAME throughout a FIFTEEN YEAR CAREER!!!!
PS: Yes, penalties in this suck. Shooting for goal is quite a bit more realistic, at least, a lot less frustrating and not as embarrassingly bad as FIFA 10. Too much topspin on the ball when you shoot straight at goal with your instep though.
On the other hand, possession changes FAR too quickly, it is difficult to keep the ball at the best of times. This I do not understand, because EA were boasting about how you'd have to build up play to score. Long balls are far more effective.
Overall though, a better-looking, more refined game than FIFA 10. Worth buying if you want the updates on kits, teams etc. However, don't buy if you're not that into football. Lastly, for more skilled players, I suggest moving your settings onto all manual for a greater challenge; the game plays better like this.
Its game play isn't even better than FIFA 10. AI sucks, AI players can not score empty goal, and in one on one situation they are horrible.
Player slip, passing is not good, I can not finish more than four passes in a row. Dribbling is very hard, no freedom of playing at all.
Player visuals = Good
Celebrations = Better then Fifa 10.
Game play = Rubbish
Passing = Rubbish
The game play lets down a very nice looking game, the demo played very goo but the full game seems toned down compared to the Demo.
I also enjoy the fact that u have to submit a transfer fee to the team, then depending on whether or not they accept it you get to negotiate with the player. So much more realistic than Fifa 10 in that aspect. Overall, great game. An improvment over Fifa 10.
And what the matter with the ball protection. It was ok in FIFA10. Now it looks like nothing! I konow british players are note very skillfull and not using sole a lot but...
The last thing i have to say is that PES has the Libertadores cup. Not FIFA... shame. And most of all, you make brazilian teams and players playin there very weak. Look at the intercontinental cups and you'll see if they suck so much... Shame again.
few menu irritations.
fantastic gameplay on MANUAL. reminiscent of old PES games.
EXCELLENT WORK BY EA SPORTS.but u better step it up even more fore 2012.
shout out to all sydney fc fans.
hopefully this will be fixed by the custom crowd chants they have brought it
PES SUCKS BALLS
Comments are closed.